Skip to main content

Patterns for service-oriented IT

Last week we attended a workshop that brought together people from universities across the UK who are working on various forms of Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) to underpin their business IT.  The workshop was organised by Nikki Rogers at the University of Bristol.  Bristol have the the foresight to employ Nikki as a full-time enterprise architect, which they should be congratulated on.  Nikki has written an excellent report of the workshop on her blog.  (Her blog is worth subscribing to, by the way).

What struck me about the day was the variety of architectural patterns that people were pursuing under the general heading of SOA.  This echoed our own situation at Edinburgh, where we have got some traction for the basic ideas of service-orientation and now have to articulate our vision for the next steps. 

Cardiff University, for example, are basically implementing a real-time data warehouse, with web services making the data available to downstream systems.  The data warehouse includes data from the student record, staff database, and finance systems, brought into a common model.  It serves as the source of data both for their business intelligence (BI) initiative and for the aforementioned web services.

At Edinburgh, we have a similar but more ad-hoc system for distributing student record data, and we have our own BI intiative which is looking at data warehousing.  I had not realised that it was possible to combine the two, as I thought data warehouses were updated nightly or even weekly.  I learnt from Cardiff that the technology has now advanced so that the data warehouses can be kept up to date, lagging only a few minutes from the "golden copy" sources.

By contrast, Imperial College London are building a classic SOA architecture, in which multiple business services are orchestrated by the SOA middleware.  This is the approach that is most clearly supported by our current SOA technology, Oracle SOA Suite.  It is no coincidence that Imperial also use this technology.  By contrast, Cardiff started down this route almost a decade ago but have retreated from it, partly because "they don't have services to orchestrate".

A third approach is event-driven SOA, which was exemplified by the University of Lincoln.  In this approach, each data update is announced to a range of services, which can take any action they need to.  This combines the data-driven aspect of Cardiff's approach with the service-based aspect.  It gives a more loosely coupled interation that the centrally orchestrated approach of classis SOA.  A central aspect of this approach is an Enterprise Service Bus, which is the mechanism for announcing each event to the relevant services.

At Edinburgh, our discussions often assume we are taking the event-driven approach to SOA.  However, we haven't really implemented this yet.  We don't have a range of underlying services.  Our chosen SOA software is better at supporting the orchestration model, and our IT mindset hasn't really caught up with the idea of calling services rather than moving data.  In many cases, we are integrating third-party systems and we really do need to transfer data between systems.  So my priority is to clarify these different approaches, explain them to our stakeholders, and decide when we want to use each one.




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A new EA Repository

One of my goals since starting this job two years ago has always been to create a repository for architecture documents.  The idea is to have a central store where people can find information about the University's applications, data sources, business processes, and other architectural information.  This store will make it easier for us to explain our plans, to show the current state of the University's information systems, and to explain what Enterprise Architecture is all about.

It's taken a long time to reach this goal, mainly because we're often had more pressing and immediate work to be done.  The creation of a repository is one of those tasks that is very important but never quite urgent.  So I'm now very happy to say that we are in the process of deploying a repository and modelling tool.


This is the culmination of a careful process to select the most appropriate tool for our needs.  We began by organising several workshops to gather requirements from a rang…

A brief summary of our major initiatives

I notice that in 2016 I wrote 34 posts on this blog.  This is only my fifth post in 2017 and we're already three-quarters of the way through the year.  Either I've suddenly got lazier, or else I've had less time to spend writing here.  As I'm not inclined to think of myself as especially lazy, I'm plumping for the latter explanation.

There really is a lot going on.  The University has several major initiatives under way, many of which need input from the Enterprise Architecture section.

The Service Excellence programme is overhauling (the buzzword is "transforming") our administrative processes for HR, Finance, and Student Administration.  Linked to this is a programme to procure an integrated ERP system to replace the adminstrative IT systems. 

Enabling Digital Transformation is a programme to put the middleware and architecture in place so that we can make our processes "digital first".  We're implementing an API framework, a notification…

Business Model Canvas

A Business Model Canvas is a tool for mapping the core functions and capabilities of an organisation.  Compared to the Core Diagrams that I described in an earlier post, the business model canvas attempts to present more aspects of the business, starting with the value proposition – a statement of what the organisation offers to its users (in the business world, to its customers).  It shows the activities and resources, as Core Diagrams do, but also shows user relationships & channels, and also benefits and costs.  I’m not aware of any universities that have used this tool but you can find examples from elsewhere on the web.

We are considering business model canvases as a tool for mapping the strategic capabilities of units at the University of Edinburgh.  Phil Taylor, our EA contractor, sketched an outline of what a business model canvas might begin to look like for HR:
This is only intended to be suggestive: the real canvas would need to result from in-depth discussions about th…